1
Define the case for support with a specific outcome
Write one to three sentences that state the problem, what your organization does about it, and the measurable result the campaign will fund. Avoid mission-statement language β anchor it to a specific program or project.
π‘ Test your case with someone outside the organization. If they cannot repeat back the impact in their own words, it needs to be simpler and more concrete.
2
Set the total goal and break it into channel sub-goals
Start with your overall revenue target, then allocate it across major gifts, annual fund, events, and grants based on prior-year results and capacity. Each sub-goal should have its own timeline and owner.
π‘ In most campaigns, major gifts account for 60β80% of total revenue from 10β20% of donors β build the gift table before finalizing the overall goal.
3
Segment prospects by capacity and relationship stage
Pull your donor or prospect database and sort by largest prior gift, recency, and engagement indicators. Group into major gift, mid-level, general, and new-prospect tiers with a distinct ask amount and approach for each.
π‘ Lapsed donors who gave 12β36 months ago are typically the highest-conversion segment for reactivation β prioritize them before cold prospecting.
4
Map solicitation channels to each segment
Assign at least two to three touchpoints per segment across the campaign window. For major gift prospects, the sequence is typically cultivation meeting, written proposal, and decision conversation. For mass segments, it is email, direct mail, and phone or digital follow-up.
π‘ Calendar every touchpoint now, before the strategy is approved β open calendar space disappears fast once a campaign begins.
5
Build the campaign timeline from the ask date backward
Pick your target solicitation dates for each segment, then work backward to schedule cultivation activities, research deadlines, proposal drafting, and approval cycles.
π‘ Add two weeks of buffer before every major solicitation date β proposals, board approvals, and print production routinely run late.
6
Assign named owners to every workstream
List each campaign component β major gifts, direct mail, events, digital, grants β and name one person accountable for execution. Document their responsibilities and the reporting cadence.
π‘ If a workstream has no named owner by the time the strategy is approved, treat it as unfunded β it will not happen without accountability.
7
Complete the budget with staff time included
Total all hard costs (printing, postage, events, advertising, software) and add an estimate of staff hours by role and hourly cost. Calculate projected CPDR for each channel and flag any channel above $0.50.
π‘ Channels with CPDR above $0.50 are rarely worth keeping unless they serve a donor acquisition or relationship-building purpose beyond immediate revenue.
8
Set mid-campaign checkpoints and contingency triggers
Define at least two review dates before the campaign close. At each checkpoint, specify the minimum threshold β percentage of goal reached, number of major gift decisions received β that triggers a contingency tactic.
π‘ Document the contingency tactic in the strategy now, not when you need it. A pre-agreed response (extend the campaign, activate a matching gift, increase digital spend) avoids reactive decision-making under pressure.