1
Complete the header with candidate and role details
Enter the candidate's full name, the exact job title, department, interview date, and your name before the interview begins. This links the completed form to the right hire record.
π‘ Pre-fill the position and department fields in a master template version so interviewers never leave them blank.
2
Review the role requirements summary before the interview
Read the role purpose statement and the three core competencies being assessed. Confirm they still match the current job description β requirements sometimes shift between when the form was created and when the interview takes place.
π‘ If a panel of interviewers is sharing the form, assign each interviewer one or two specific competencies to probe in depth rather than having everyone cover everything.
3
Ask background questions and take concise notes
Work through the background and experience questions in order. Write brief notes on the candidate's responses β paraphrase their key points rather than transcribing verbatim.
π‘ Note specific job titles, company names, and project outcomes the candidate mentions β these are the details you will need when comparing candidates days later.
4
Probe technical knowledge with the scenario questions
Present the technical question as written. If the candidate's answer is surface-level, use a prepared probing follow-up such as 'What would you do if [COMPLICATION]?' to test depth.
π‘ Avoid telegraphing the 'right' answer through your tone or phrasing β let the candidate's reasoning emerge without steering.
5
Record behavioral responses in full STAR format
For each behavioral question, note whether the candidate provided a complete Situation, Task, Action, and Result. If they omit the Result, prompt them: 'What was the outcome?'
π‘ Results should be specific and ideally quantified β 'improved turnaround by three days' is useful; 'made things faster' is not.
6
Score each competency immediately after the interview
Complete the scoring grid within 30 minutes of the interview ending, while the evidence is fresh. Record the specific quote or observation that supports each score.
π‘ Score against the rubric criteria, not against other candidates you have already interviewed β comparative scoring inflates or deflates ratings based on the pool rather than the standard.
7
Write the overall recommendation with a cited rationale
Select Advance, Hold, or Decline and write two to three sentences citing specific evidence from the form. Reference scores and examples, not impressions.
π‘ If you are on a panel, complete your recommendation independently before comparing with other interviewers β this prevents anchoring bias from the first person who speaks.